Justice in Robes

Justice in Robes

How should a judge's moral convictions bear on his judgments about what the law is? Lawyers, sociologists, philosophers, politicians, and judges all have answers to that question: these range from ÒnothingÓ to Òeverything.Ó In Justice in Robes, Ronald Dworkin argues that the question is much more complex than it has often been taken to be and charts a variety of dimensionsÑsemantic, jurisprudential, and doctrinalÑin which law and morals are undoubtedly interwoven. He restates and summarizes his own widely discussed account of these connections, which emphasizes the sovereign importance of moral principle in legal and constitutional interpretation, and then reviews and criticizes the most influential rival theories to his own. He argues that pragmatism is empty as a theory of law, that value pluralism misunderstands the nature of moral concepts, that constitutional originalism reflects an impoverished view of the role of a constitution in a democratic society, and that contemporary legal positivism is based on a mistaken semantic theory and an erroneous account of the nature of authority. In the course of that critical study he discusses the work of many of the most influential lawyers and philosophers of the era, including Isaiah Berlin, Richard Posner, Cass Sunstein, Antonin Scalia, and Joseph Raz. Dworkin's new collection of essays and original chapters is a model of lucid, logical, and impassioned reasoning that will advance the crucially important debate about the roles of justice in law.


Author
Publisher Harvard University Press
Release Date
ISBN 0674027272
Pages 308 pages
Rating 4/5 (75 users)

More Books:

Justice in Robes
Language: en
Pages: 308
Authors: Ronald Dworkin
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2008-04-30 - Publisher: Harvard University Press

How should a judge's moral convictions bear on his judgments about what the law is? Lawyers, sociologists, philosophers, politicians, and judges all have answer
Does Dworkin Commit Dworkin's Fallacy? A Reply to Justice in Robes
Language: en
Pages: 24
Authors: Michael S. Green
Categories:
Type: BOOK - Published: 2015 - Publisher:

In quot;Dworkin's Fallacy, Or What the Philosophy of Language Can't Teach Us About the Law,quot; I described a common fallacy among philosophers of law, in whic
Does Dworkin Commit Dworkin's Fallacy?
Language: en
Pages:
Authors: Michael Steven Green
Categories:
Type: BOOK - Published: 2010 - Publisher:

In an article entitled Dworkin's Fallacy, Or What the Philosophy of Language Can't Teach Us about the Law, I argued that in Law's Empire Ronald Dworkin misderiv
Q&A Jurisprudence 2013-2014
Language: en
Pages: 384
Authors: David Brooke
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2013-04-18 - Publisher: Routledge

Routledge Q&As give you the tools to practice and refine your exam technique, showing you how to apply your knowledge to maximum effect in an exam situation. Ea
Dimensions of Normativity
Language: en
Pages: 384
Authors: David Plunkett
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2019-01-11 - Publisher: Oxford University Press

Understood one way, the branch of contemporary philosophical ethics that goes by the label "metaethics" concerns certain second-order questions about ethics-que
Philosophical Foundations of Constitutional Law
Language: en
Pages: 350
Authors: David Dyzenhaus
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2016-02-04 - Publisher: Oxford University Press

Constitutional law has been and remains an area of intense philosophical interest, and yet the debate has taken place in a variety of different fields with very
The Mandate of Dignity
Language: en
Pages: 152
Authors: Drucilla Cornell
Categories: Political Science
Type: BOOK - Published: 2016-02-01 - Publisher: Fordham Univ Press

A major American legal thinker, the late Ronald Dworkin also helped shape new dispensations in the Global South. In South Africa, in particular, his work has be
Black Robes, White Justice
Language: en
Pages: 214
Authors: Bruce Wright
Categories: African American judges
Type: BOOK - Published: 1993 - Publisher: Lyle Stuart

The author, a New York State Supreme Court Justice and a black man, argues that our legal system is fundamentally unfair towards African Americans--and document
New Englander and Yale Review
Language: en
Pages:
Authors: Edward Royall Tyler
Categories:
Type: BOOK - Published: 1888 - Publisher:

New Englander and Yale Review
Language: en
Pages: 504
Authors:
Categories: Religion
Type: BOOK - Published: 1888 - Publisher: